GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - Printable Version +- Biotechnology Forums (https://www.biotechnologyforums.com) +-- Forum: Education and Careers (https://www.biotechnologyforums.com/forum-26.html) +--- Forum: Competitive Exams (https://www.biotechnologyforums.com/forum-38.html) +--- Thread: GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion (/thread-7776.html) |
RE: GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - masthanbasha - 02-28-2017 (02-28-2017, 06:41 PM)RahulK Wrote: I am thinking of challenging the Pedigree question for the correct answer to be "Y-Linked" inheritence only.yes rahul your explanation is absolutely correct. y linked only the answer RE: GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - RahulK - 02-28-2017 (02-28-2017, 07:21 PM)masthanbasha Wrote:(02-28-2017, 06:41 PM)RahulK Wrote: I am thinking of challenging the Pedigree question for the correct answer to be "Y-Linked" inheritence only.yes rahul your explanation is absolutely correct. y linked only the answer If we could get some views from Sunil Sir, it would be really helpful. RE: GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - RahulK - 02-28-2017 (02-28-2017, 04:55 PM)gaurang94 Wrote:(02-28-2017, 02:31 PM)masthanbasha Wrote: yes it is y linked only Please consider my explanation in the below image. RE: GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - Debasmita - 02-28-2017 Can anyone please report if they are interested in challenging the pedigree question and the mass percent question since the answer is given as 345 and many people like me have gotten it to be 115? RE: GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - RahulK - 02-28-2017 (02-28-2017, 07:53 PM)Debasmita Wrote: Can anyone please report if they are interested in challenging the pedigree question and the mass percent question since the answer is given as 345 and many people like me have gotten it to be 115? I am interested in challenging the Pedigree question, I am preparing a list of arguments to support my challenge, please let me know if you also have any arguments that can go in our favor. GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - gaurang94 - 02-28-2017 (02-28-2017, 07:51 PM)RahulK Wrote:(02-28-2017, 04:55 PM)gaurang94 Wrote: First of all, the parent don't have 4 daughters they have 2 daughters and 2 affected sons ... Yess I agree with you. atleast one of the two daughters should get affected.. I also want the answer to be y linked only.. i just drew the possible outcomes according to answer key.. RE: GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - RahulK - 02-28-2017 (02-28-2017, 08:00 PM)gaurang94 Wrote:(02-28-2017, 07:51 PM)RahulK Wrote: Please consider my explanation in the below image. Sorry for my mistake, they have 2 daughters. I am just wondering, if my arguments will hold enough to favor my challenge and will it be worth challenging. RE: GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - Debasmita - 02-28-2017 (02-28-2017, 08:06 PM)RahulK Wrote:(02-28-2017, 08:00 PM)gaurang94 Wrote: Exactly the same thing. GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - gaurang94 - 02-28-2017 (02-28-2017, 08:06 PM)RahulK Wrote:(02-28-2017, 08:00 PM)gaurang94 Wrote: First of all, the parent don't have 4 daughters they have 2 daughters and 2 affected sons ... Yess I agree with you. atleast one of the two daughters should get affected.. I also want the answer to be y linked only.. i just drew the possible outcomes according to answer key.. Yess challenging this question is definitely worth it.. Even if you just consider the gametes that can be formed from those parents eg. Xx * xY ---> Xx, XY, xx, xY If we consider x recessive causes disease.. then they should have 1 carrier daughter, 1 healthy son, 1 affected daughter, and 1 affected son.. Correct me if i am wrong. RE: GATE BT-2017 Answer Key | Solutions Discussion - RahulK - 02-28-2017 (02-28-2017, 08:14 PM)gaurang94 Wrote:(02-28-2017, 08:06 PM)RahulK Wrote: Sorry for my mistake, they have 2 daughters. You are correct Gaurang, Lets collate all our arguments and get ready to challenge the question. |